We were discussing free will vs. determinism today...and whenever I tried to express my opinion, I got interrupted. So...what the fuck. I expect to be able to discuss and debate in this class, but apparently not.
My theory, I think, is pretty sound. Most people don't believe in free will--there's a whole lot of cases against it. Determinism seems to make more sense. Well, here's my theory.
Before I get into it--yes, determinism can be supported by Newtonian physics, but they are outdated. Quantum physics are more modern and reliable.
Libertarians (I count myself one of them) believe in the Quantum theories...if Y follows X, and X is true, there is only a <i>probability</i> that Y is also true. Newtonian physics say that Y must be true if it follows the true X. Not the case. There is an infitesimal probability...yes, microscopic, but existant.
Apply this to free will vs. determinism. Most of our actions would be determined, with only a tiny part of our actions (say one in a thousand) being a result of free will. So...we only act freely once every thousand times? No. Our body performs thousands, even millions, of actions every day. My heart beats 80 times a minute. I breath in and out once every four seconds. I blink about 15 times a minute. Imagine all that, plus every other function of my body...cells regenerating, digesting, hair growing, sweating, and the nerve receptions from things I can't control, like the loud music in the apartment next door or my cat purring on my leg. I can control none of these functions--they are DETERMINED. Thus, every action I take outside of these functions is a result of my free will. My involuntary actions are determined. My voluntary actions, which are far fewer in number, are free. Writing this entry is a good example. I didn't have to. But I am, of my own choice. And think about it...of all the thousands and millions of things our bodies do every <i>hour</i> and the very few concious choices we make in that time...apparently, our choices are borne of free will...only our bodily processes are determined. Thus, we are free.
Also...keep in mind...the body and the mind are two different things. To sum it up...our bodies are determined...but our minds are uncontrolled and self-willed.
Let me know what you think of this.
mood:  contemplative music: "Somebody to Love" by Queen |